Since 1978, Sheridan’s Restaurant and Tavern, located in Andover, NJ, has been a favorite to the local community. Family owned and operated from the beginning, Sheridan’s offers warm and friendly service, good food and drink, in a unique setting overlooking beautiful Lake Iliff. Every seat in both dining rooms overlooks the lake, a mere twenty feet away. Sheridan’s serves wonderful home style meals that include chicken pot pies, steaks, pasta, meatloaf, cottage pie, burgers, incredible salads, fresh seafood and more. The bar is one of the largest in Sussex County and offers great choices of wine, cocktails and beers.

It is truly a neighborhood tavern – something that is disappearing in today’s society.



631 Limecrest Rd, Newton, NJ 07860


41.029467, -74.71654799999999

Plan My Route


Indoor and Outdoor Dining

Enjoy your meal in our spacious, newly renovated dining room or on our back deck overlooking beautiful Lake Iliff.

Craft Beers

Choose from our huge selection of craft beers both locally sourced and imported.

Game Room

Kids and adults alike enjoy our game room with video games, pool, and a dart board.

Party Room

Reserve our private party room for your next gathering!

Late Night Drink Specials

$2 PBR cans and $3 well drinks every Sunday through Thursday.


Ask about about catering your next event!